Get Started

Show Me the Money: Quantifying the Real ROI of Digital Payments in FMCG (2025)

FMCG payments don’t just move cash; they create measurable value across your P&L—lower landed cost, faster shelf availability, higher distributor trust, and tighter working-capital turns. Yet many CFOs still struggle to prove the upside in numbers, not anecdotes. This playbook shows exactly how to quantify the FMCG payments ROI of going digital in 2025—what to measure, how to measure it, and which benchmarks matter. You’ll walk away with a repeatable model your finance team can run every quarter, tied to business outcomes your board cares about.

FMCG payments

Why 2025 Is the Year to Measure FMCG Payments ROI

Two big shifts make quantifying FMCG payments ROI easier—and more urgent—this year.

First, the global push to improve cross-border payments (the G20/BIS/CPMI roadmap) sets explicit targets on cost, speed, transparency, and access by end-2027. These are the exact dimensions your ROI math should track. (See the programme overview and targets.) (https://www.bis.org/cpmi/cross_border.htm) (https://www.bis.org/cpmi/cross_border/programme.htm) Bank for International Settlements+1

Second, the industry migration to ISO 20022 messaging reaches a hard milestone in November 2025 when the CBPR+ coexistence period ends, improving data structure for names, addresses, and purpose codes—the raw material for accurate ROI measurement and higher straight-through processing. (https://www.swift.com/standards/iso-20022/iso-20022-faqs/implementation) (https://www.swift.com/standards/iso-20022/iso-20022-bytes/iso-20022-bytes-payments-countdown-iso-20022) Swift+1

As a friction proxy, World Bank monitoring still shows global average remittance costs around 6.49% (site last updated Aug 18, 2025). Corporate flows are different from retail remittances, but the signal is clear: many corridors remain costly and inconsistent—meaning the ROI pool from better routing, data, rails, and FX is still large. (https://remittanceprices.worldbank.org/) (https://remittanceprices.worldbank.org/data-download) Remittance Prices Worldwide+1

The CFO’s ROI Formula for FMCG Payments

Start with a simple, defensible model:

ROI (%) = (Total Annualized Benefits − Total Annualized Costs) ÷ Total Annualized Costs × 100

Where Benefits aggregate quantifiable improvements across five buckets of FMCG payments performance:

Your controller will ask: “What’s auditable?” Answer: everything, if you structure data properly under ISO 20022 and log events across the payment journey—draft → approve → screen → release → reconcile. (https://www.swift.com/standards/iso-20022/iso-20022-faqs/implementation) Swift

21 Proven Value Levers and How to Quantify Each

Below are field-tested levers. For each, we explain the FMCG payments logic and the exact calculation to drop into your ROI model.

1) FX spread reduction

Logic: Multi-dealer RFQ and portfolio hedging shrink basis-point leakage on big tickets.
Calc: (Baseline average spread − post-program spread) × notional volume of hedged flows.

2) Lower partner/bank fees

Logic: Corridor-aware routing and volume commitments drive better pricing.
Calc: Sum of per-payment fee reductions × payment count.

3) Fewer repair/reject fees

Logic: ISO 20022 structured fields (name, address, purpose code) reduce manual interventions.
Calc: (Baseline repair rate − post-program repair rate) × average repair fee × payments. (ISO 20022 context.) (https://www.swift.com/standards/iso-20022/iso-20022-bytes/iso-20022-bytes-payments-countdown-iso-20022) Swift

4) Time-to-cash improvement

Logic: Faster settlement means less buffer inventory and lower lost sales risk.
Calc: Hours saved × hourly cost of capital for inventory + sales uplift during promos.

5) Cut-off adherence

Logic: Fewer missed cut-offs avoid day-slips in distributor credit.
Calc: (Missed cut-off baseline − after) × average value-at-risk per day × frequency.

6) Instant-rail utilization

Logic: Where credible, near-real-time payout reduces inquiries and accelerates sell-in.
Calc: Incremental same-day delivery rate × average gross margin per case in promo windows. (Roadmap context on speed/transparency.) (https://www.bis.org/cpmi/cross_border.htm) Bank for International Settlements

7) Working-capital release

Logic: Aligning FMCG payments to milestones (customs cleared, DC receipt) compresses cash-to-cash.
Calc: Days reduced × daily cost of capital × average AP balance.

8) Local-currency settlement

Logic: Distributors get certainty; fewer disputes and faster reorders.
Calc: Dispute rate reduction × average dispute cost + reorder frequency uplift × contribution margin.

9) Exception automation

Logic: Guided workflows on bounce/repair cut manual hours.
Calc: Hours saved per exception × hourly cost × exceptions.

10) Reconciliation automation

Logic: Enriched references enable straight-through matching.
Calc: (Baseline recon hours − after) × hourly cost × monthly cycles.

11) Compliance false-positive reduction

Logic: Cleaner data reduces manual reviews.
Calc: (False-positive baseline − after) × handling hours × hourly cost.

12) Onboarding velocity

Logic: Faster supplier/distributor onboarding → earlier revenue capture.
Calc: Days saved × average daily sales at distributor launch × conversion rate.

13) Rate-cap protection

Logic: Rate-cap or collar structures limit adverse FX in volatile weeks.
Calc: Avoided slippage (bps) × exposure × frequency.

14) Corridor dual-rail resiliency

Logic: A second route prevents throttling delays and lost selling days.
Calc: Avoided downtime days × average daily margin at risk.

15) Smart scheduling

Logic: Align send windows to corridor cut-offs and liquidity.
Calc: Day-slip reduction × value-at-risk per day × payments/month.

16) Data completeness score

Logic: Each percent of completeness lowers repairs and speeds screens.
Calc: Improvement in score × historical elasticity of repair rate × repair cost.

17) Status traceability

Logic: Proactive status updates cut distributor inquiries and credits.
Calc: Inquiry reduction × handling time × hourly cost + avoided credits.

18) Purpose-code consistency

Logic: Better screening outcomes with clear payment purpose.
Calc: Hold reduction × average time-on-hold cost × escalations.

19) Bulk FX netting

Logic: Netting recurring flows reduces tickets and spread.
Calc: Tickets reduced × avg ticket fee + spread improvement × netted volume.

20) Digital audit trail

Logic: Faster audits free finance capacity.
Calc: Audit hours saved × hourly cost × audits/year.

21) Supplier early-settlement discounts (selective)

Logic: Use instant payout strategically to capture early-pay discounts when ROI exceeds cost.
Calc: Discount value − cost of capital − transaction cost.

If you need market context for the size of the prize, the McKinsey Global Payments Report 2024 details how complexity and fragmentation keep corporate payment costs elevated—fertile ground for the savings levers above. (https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/financial-services/our-insights/global-payments-in-2024-simpler-interfaces-complex-reality) McKinsey & Company

FMCG payments ROI in the Real World: Asia, Africa, LATAM

Asia. As cross-border linkages and instant paradigms spread, your ROI model should capture same-day/instant shares where feasible and the knock-on effect on promo sell-through. Tie benefits to faster FMCG payments and lower inquiry volume.

Africa. Mobile-money ecosystems are now mainstream rails and interfaces for value flows; GSMA’s 2024/2025 findings show record user growth and transaction values across the region—evidence that digital rails can carry significant, recurring commerce. (https://www.gsma.com/solutions-and-impact/connectivity-for-good/mobile-for-development/gsma_resources/state-of-the-industry-report-on-mobile-money-2024/) (https://communicationsafrica.com/mobile/mobile-money-booms-in-africa-gsma-report) GSMACommunications Africa

LATAM. Domestic instant schemes (e.g., Brazil’s Pix) drive expectations of speed and transparency; even when your payout is cross-border, your ROI model should quantify reconciliation time saved and on-time settlement improvements as logistics hits tighter SLAs.

Wherever you operate, keep one external barometer in your dashboard: the World Bank’s RPW trend. If retail corridors still average 6.49%, your enterprise corridors likely have room for improvement—your ROI thesis. (https://remittanceprices.worldbank.org/) Remittance Prices Worldwide

Methodology: Data, Controls, and ISO 20022

It’s impossible to argue about ROI if your FMCG payments data is unstructured. That’s what ISO 20022 fixes.

Map fields now. Ensure legal names, structured addresses, and purpose codes are captured in your ERP/TMS export. With CBPR+ coexistence ending on 22 Nov 2025, laggards will face more friction and worse metrics. (https://www.swift.com/standards/iso-20022/iso-20022-faqs/implementation) (https://www.swift.com/sites/default/files/files/swift-iso-20022-end-of-coexistence-guide.pdf) Swift+1

Instrument your journey. Log draft, approval, screening hits, release time, settlement confirmation, and reconciliation result for every payment. Use those event stamps to compute time-to-cash and exception cycle times.

Create corridor baselines. For each lane, store cost per $1,000, settlement time, repair rate, and false-positive rate. Compare to G20 dimensions of cost/speed/transparency/access to keep your ROI aligned to global targets. (https://www.bis.org/cpmi/cross_border.htm) Bank for International Settlements

Before/After Baselines: Your 90-Day ROI Pilot

A fast pilot proves value and calibrates your model for scale.

Month 1 — Baseline. Select 8–12 high-value corridors. Measure the 10 most material KPIs: all-in cost per $1,000; FX slippage vs budget; on-time settlement; average settlement time; repair rate; false-positive rate; exception cycle time; reconciliation time; instant/ same-day share; and inquiry volume.

Month 2 — Interventions.

Month 3 — Measurement. Re-run the KPIs. Convert every improvement into dollars: fees avoided, hours saved, working-capital released, and margin preserved. Your quarter-one FMCG payments ROI becomes the baseline for the budget cycle.

Pro tip: Keep a public benchmark in the deck—G20 roadmap targets and RPW averages—to frame the “why now” narrative. (https://www.bis.org/cpmi/cross_border/programme.htm) (https://remittanceprices.worldbank.org/) Bank for International SettlementsRemittance Prices Worldwide

Risk-Adjusted ROI: FX, Compliance, and Exceptions

ROI must be robust under stress.

FX swings. Use a portfolio view of exposures, not ticket-by-ticket, and measure realized slippage weekly. Tie hedge decisions to corridor tiers and promotion calendars so FMCG payments remain predictable when markets move. Context from the McKinsey 2024 report: behind simpler interfaces, complexity and fragmentation raise the stakes for disciplined execution. (https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/financial-services/our-insights/global-payments-in-2024-simpler-interfaces-complex-reality) McKinsey & Company

Compliance holds. Track touch rate and false-positive rate. Cleaner ISO 20022 data reduces both—lift this into your ROI line as hours saved and delays avoided. (https://www.swift.com/standards/iso-20022/iso-20022-bytes/iso-20022-bytes-payments-countdown-iso-20022) Swift

Exceptions. Tie each exception category to a cost curve (hours + risk of lost sales). As exception cycle time drops, your ROI rises—especially in peak season when one day of delay means an empty shelf.

Storytelling with Numbers: Turning ROI into Budget

Boards don’t buy tools; they buy outcomes. Present FMCG payments ROI with three crisp exhibits:

  1. Waterfall of Value. From spread and fees to time, working capital, productivity, and risk—show dollars by lever.
  2. Corridor Rankings. Where improvements hit fastest (e.g., Africa via mobile-money payout; Asia with instant corridors; LATAM with reconciliation wins). Include an external benchmark sidebar—G20 dimensions and RPW averages—to anchor credibility. (https://www.bis.org/cpmi/cross_border.htm) (https://remittanceprices.worldbank.org/) Bank for International SettlementsRemittance Prices Worldwide
  3. Payback Curve. Implementation costs vs monthly benefit; show break-even date and 12-month IRR.

Round it out with a compliance annex noting the November 22, 2025 CBPR+ date—your case for ISO data quality and automation urgency. (https://www.swift.com/standards/iso-20022/iso-20022-faqs/implementation) Swift

Implement Faster with FMCG Pay (CTA)

You could assemble these capabilities from a dozen vendors—or use one platform built for FMCG payments. FMCG Pay gives you corridor-aware routing, ISO 20022-ready messaging, automated compliance, instant-rail options where credible, and a control tower that converts raw events into auditable ROI. Your teams stop chasing emails and start improving KPIs.

error: Content is protected !!